Eating In Season

Seasonal Fiddlehead Greens

There is little doubt that eating certain fiddlehead greens can significantly increase ones chances of cancer. In fact, science says they cause cancer. On the surface that would be a sobering thought but is it?

Eating? Toxic?

Toxicity can be a matter of degrees

This may sound a bit picky, but what is “eating?” And for this discussion, what is “toxic?” In broad terms there isn’t much issue: Eating is consuming food and toxic can make you sick or kill you. Eat water hemlock and you will die in a couple of hours. That’s fairly straight forward. What about eating a pound of onions a day? It may take a few weeks or months but they can kill you, too. So are they toxic? Are they deadly?

But, back to fiddleheads. Phrases like “fiddlehead greens can significantly increase ones chances of cancer” are surprisingly unqualified. That is because science, that wonderful tool, is reductionist. It does not and cannot have a Gestalt view.

What if I ate just a few fiddleheads in a few meals just in spring, when they are in season? Can I expect cancer from them 20 or 30 years down the road? What if I can them, and eat a whole lot of them throughout the year for 20 or 30 years? Might that be the cause of cancer in the time to come? Research has shown that you can get cancer by drinking the local water where fiddleheads grow. But the again, we drink water everyday, not just a few times every spring.

A Pack A Day

One cigarette does little damage

Perhaps some plants cause disease when they are eaten extra-seasonally, or to excess, or over a long period of time. A few fiddlehead every spring might actually be good for you, like a little wine, some greenery after a long winter. Preserving them and eating them all year might be akin to smoking, damage by excess or prolonged consumption. One cigarette a month is probably not going to kill you, but a pack a day can.

Simple Carbs

We used to call them “empty calories.”

It might be that man lives best when he eats seasonally, which brings me to carbohydrates. Simple carbs used to be a seasonal part of man’s diet, a fruit tree in the fall is a good example. He would eat until stuffed and the excess went to fat for winter use when the days were lean. Now most of us eat simple carbs every day, if not every meal. The

Almost as empty…

government even recommends it! But what if simple carbs are like fiddlehead greens or even cigarettes. Now and then, in season, no harm but daily deadly? Might that be what’s behind our obesity epidemic and our diabetes epidemic, the proliferation of simple carbs to the exclusion of other food?

Most of us no longer eat seasonally, and maybe that is catching up with us.

{ 5 comments }

Where the Weeds Are

There is little doubt that man has been foraging for food for a long time. As one might guess, in different places he foraged for different plants. He also foraged before there were cities and suburbia. Foraging continued well into the 1900’s, and of course, selectively today.

Among the challenges of teaching foraging is finding suitable sites. In my classes I tend to visit the same areas, at least four times a year, usually more often. Almost all of these sites are in suburbia, not in the wild. This surprises people because they assume wild food is out in the wilderness.  When the famous Willie Sutton was asked why he robbed banks, he said because that’s where the money is. I teach foraging in suburbia because that’s where the plants are.

That said, I have to qualify that comment. There are edibles in the wilds, but they tend to be different than those found in population centers and represent more a subsistence living than variety.

Many edible weeds, perhaps the majority, are not native. They are from somewhere else. They come with humans and humans go to population centers.

In an old city park I can usually find 60 to 100 edible species and I usually have to walk only a mile or so. In a state park I can walk 10 miles and find perhaps two dozen edible species. This is not to say native food is inferior or rare. It is better to say the choice is limited. But when you combine native and imported plants (and edible ornamentals) then one has a large menu.

The other reason I use city parks is because most of the species we find there most folks can also find in their own yard or neighborhood. It’s good to learn what the natives ate to survive but most folks want to find food around their own home, not a distant park (where foraging is probably also illegal.)

Foraging in suburbia does raise the issue of pollution, and that has to be taken into consideration. Despite that complication foraging in suburbia is where more people forage today. It is where most people find their wild food, and it’s where I teach. Willie Sutton would understand.

{ 0 comments }

Foraging for Beginners

I was asked to write a short piece for a survivalist blog on getting started in foraging:

How are a Musician and a Botanist Alike?

As a professional musician I often meet other musicians who teach at the college level. What you may not know is most of them cannot play something as simple as Happy Birthday without music. Yet there are thousands, perhaps millions of non-degreed musicians who play very well without music, and often at the highest level of performance.

I have read many times that the great Italian tenor Luciano Pavarotti could not read music, and that is quite reasonable. He wanted to be the best lyric tenor of Italian opera, which is a limited amount of music, perhaps just a few dozen well-known tunes. He did not need to play piano or read music to remember thirty or forty songs which were also popular where he grew up.

Like college pianists who can’t play by ear, most of the degreed botanists would starve tomorrow if the grocery stores closed. Most of the people who have foraged and who do forage are not botanists. And like Pavarotti, foragers really only need to learn a few prime edibles in their local area.

What Do I Need To Know?

While there are thousands of wild edibles, in most places there really are only a half a dozen or so species really worth knowing, from a survival point of view.

Indeed, if you can learn six prime food plants and say three medicinal plants you can survive quite well.

You don’t need a degree in botany.

You don’t need to know the Latin names.

You don’t need to know all the plants that are out there.

You only need to learn just a few edibles, a few medicinals, and it also wouldn’t hurt to know if you have any deadly plants nearby, which are usually just a few as well. That may total a dozen plants. You can learn a dozen plants.  With a teacher this can be done in a season. Without a teacher it can still be done, it just takes more time.

Cattails and Blackberries and Hemlocks, Oh My!

To get you started I will list an edible, a medicinal, and a poisonous pair that are found just about everywhere in North America. The edible is the cattail.

The cattail is nearly impossible to misidentify. Tall, strap-like with horizontal roots it grows in water or where it is very damp. It has the famous fuzzy “cattail” on top (you should always look for last year’s cattails to be sure.) Nothing grows more starch per acre than cattails, and you don’t have to tend it. While one can eat various green parts of the plant at different times of the year the root is always full of starch. Roast it to a crisp next to a fire, open, and then pull the starch off the fibers with your teeth, kind of like eating taffy.

The medicinal (and edible) is the blackberry. A cane or a vine with spines and five petaled white blossoms that turn into an aggregate, edible purple/black fruit. The leaves can be dried to make a tasty tea which is also good for various digestive disorders including  diarrhea. That tea can also be a marinade or the leaves used to stuff fish or fowl. Young shoots are edible if peeled and boiled. Indians whipped blackberries and fish eggs together to make a cream-like froth which they then froze and enjoyed.

The poisonous plant is the hemlock and its close relative the water hemlock. (Not the tree.) Large and leafy, they can grow to six feet or so on dry land or in water. The stem is smooth, often splotched with purple, often has vertical ridges. The flower looks like a fireworks explosion as does the seed head. But they both have one prime identifying characteristic: On the surface of the leaf, most of the veins clearly end in the notches between the teeth. In most plants the veins peter out or end at the tips of the teeth. Veins on the hemlocks clearly end between the teeth. They are a poison you should know because they can kill you in two hours. If you get to the hospital within 40 minutes of eating you might survive. The toxicity increases as you go down the plant, the seeds the least, the root the most. According to those who have consumed said, it is supposed to be very tasty raw or cooked (thus remember, taste does NOT indicate edibility.)

You Can Do It!

In every area there are a limited number of prime edibles, a limited number of really useful medicinals, and a limited number of deadly plants. You can learn to identify them, and ignore the rest. You can tell the difference between a horse and a cow, a cow and a buffalo, a dog and a fox, a fox and a cat. You can tell plants apart. You can do it. You don’ t need to learn the whole green world out there or be a botanist. You just need to learn a few “tunes.”

{ 20 comments }

Mole Crickets and Lawns

The name of my website is “Eat The Weeds (and other things too.)” If you wander around the long index — or click on the category “critter cuisine” — you will find other edibles, such as anoles, scorpions, grubs and snails and things like that. To expand choices I have been adding edible insects. No, I am not going to launch into a lecture on how if we ate more insects we could save the world. But…

Those who follow my writing know I do not care for lawns as residential features. They just aren’t green. They’re fine for golf courses and cemeteries, but I think a lawn with every home is a costly affectation. How costly? Let’s look at one little corner of it.

Lawn + Cricket = No Fun

Locally there are three mole crickets, ugly-looking burrowing insects. Two of them arrived here from South American about a century ago and are a disaster to lawns. In fact, we spend hundreds — hundreds — of millions of dollars to get rid of mole crickets, and yes they are edible. In some parts of the world they are close to a protein staple.

If we didn’t have lawns we wouldn’t have a mole cricket problem, we wouldn’t spend hundreds of millions of dollars, and I’d have a few less bugs to eat. In a goodwill gesture I will give up mole crickets if folks give up their lawns. I really just want to point out that the idea that we must have lawns leads to we must fight mole crickets. Getting rid of lawns just isn’t in that thought process, nor is eating mole crickets, nutritious as they are. (See Mole Cricket, Kamaro)

I have a difficult enough time getting people to eat weeds so I’m not even going to try to get folks to eat insects. They are either interested or they are not.  But it does seem to me the money spend on lawns and defending them could be better spent elsewhere.

{ 0 comments }

Dog and Cat

Your pets are off limits, others’ pets are not

Most Westerners would starve than eat their pet, and understandably so. There is a tacit agreement between pets and their owners.  In exchange for putting down their natural defenses the animal accepts your promise not to harm or eat them. There is a function of trust operating. However, the neighbor’s dog who barks all night or cat that uses others’ lawns for a bathroom enjoys no such protection. To many Westerners pets are personal but non-personal pets are free game, so to speak.

Besides the pet issue there is another aspect to eating dogs and cats. Generally animals for consumption are plant eaters: Cattle, Fowl, Lambs, Pigs, Rabbits, various ground and swamp rodents, squirrel, deer even horse (which was on Harvard’s menu until the 80s.) .

Humans usually don’t eat other carnivores

Carnivores, meat eaters, usually are not on the menu. Humans tend to not eat other meat eaters. Humans tend to eat plant eaters. I don’t know why most humans don’t eat meat eaters. It might be an issue of taste or some distant respect to another carnivore.  One common exception is humans eat fish, and most fish live off other fish. Despite that fish is not called meat by some. Many people in many cultures don’t eat certain animals for many reasons. In Colonial America lobster and crab were considered disgusting trash. When I was a kid, mussels were below contempt. Now they are in gourmet markets. Some suggest dogs and cats are one possible answer to world hunger. Others might argue cat should be available in health food stores.  Cat meat is high in protein, low in calories with very little cholesterol and saturated fats. Perhaps it can get the American Heart Association’s stamp of approval.

My introduction to carnivore meat was bear sausage at a very fancy restaurant. Bears are wild and though a distant relative of the dog it fell into the wilderness food realm.  It was spicy, substantial, and quite good.

Euell Gibbons

One time the well-known forager Euell Gibbons and a friend were hunting in Canada. They were still empty-handed after a few days in the wilds and had planned on shooting what meat they would need. Eventually they managed to shoot a bobcat. That evening they roasted the bobcat over a fire, their first meat in several days. Gibbons said his friend said the “bob” part tasted good but the “cat” part didn’t. (Not all agree: Chinese billionaire Long Liyuan loved eating cat. In fact he was murdered on 23 December 2011 when one of his dinner companions poison his cat stew with Gelsemium elegans.) And had Gibbons and his hunting partner been in California they might have been arrested. Henry Arniba, a 38-year old man from Morgan Hill, California, who lived in a trailer with 40 roosters, was arrested on 8 Nov. 2011 when police investigating a report of illegal marijuana growing found the remains of a bobcat on the property. The man said he shot the bobcat because it attacked and ate a few of his roosters. Then he decided to eat the bobcat. It is illegal to kill bobcat in California without a license but not illegal to eat it. No marijuana was found but cockfighting implements were discovered and some methamphetamine. The case was not resolved as of June 2012.

Norwegian explorer Roald Amundsen who was first to the South Pole was known to have eaten sled dogs during his expedition. By eating some of the sled dogs, he was required to carry less human and dog food, lightening his load. He wrote:
“…there is the obvious advantage that dog can be fed on dog. One can reduce one’s pack little by little, slaughtering the feebler ones and feeding the chosen with them. In this way they get fresh meat. Our dogs lived on dog’s flesh and pemmican the whole way, and this enabled them to do splendid work. And if we ourselves wanted a piece of fresh meat we could cut off a delicate little fillet; it tasted to us as good as the best beef. The dogs do not object at all; as long as they get their share they do not mind what part of their comrade’s carcass it comes from. All that was left after one of these canine meals was the teeth of the victim – and if it had been a really hard day, these also disappeared.”

Dog in Vietnam

It is also something of an irony that Switzerland, which is well-known for not having a memorable cuisine, is Europe’s center of dog consumption. They eat cat as well, as do the Basque. Not only do the Swiss have many dog recipes but dog jerky and sausage are also esteemed. No word on dog and chocolate together. Dog meat is flavorful and tasty. If overfed, also fatty. Note: In New York and California eating of dog is illegal. On the other hand in some countries there are dogs specifically raised for food.

By the way, like bear liver dog liver is very toxic to humans, and the older the dog the more toxic. Seal and walrus liver is also toxic. What these animals have in common is a liver that stores high amounts of vitamin A. A diet that includes dog liver can be fatal to humans. Antarctic explore Xavier Mertz (c. 1883 – 8 January 1913) is believed to have died from it. As it is not likely to be detected some speculate it has been successfully used as a murder weapon: Death by dog liver.

Walking your dog and woking your cat

When my cats misbehave I tell them that in a roasting pan there is little visual difference between a rabbit and a cat. While cat is on the menu in some South American countries — and the Australian Aboriginals eat them as well — the epicenter of cat cuisine of the world is Guangdong province in China. A media report in 2008 said 10,000 cats per day are eaten in the province which is some 3.65 million cats a year. This is quite different in California where it is illegal to consume them. You do see the difference don’t you? In California it is illegal to kill a wild bobcat but not illegal to eat it. In California it is illegal to eat a domestic cat but not illegal to kill it.  One Jason Louis Wilmert, 36, found that out. He was arrested in February 2012 for preparing cats to eat or eating cats in his home. He plea bargained and got three years probation, community service, and ordered to seek mental health counseling.

Feral Feline

In other states Wilmert’s actions would have been legal. Local law here requires the animal be killed humanely and not be worried…. read you can’t kill a cow with a pack of dogs. In my distant past I was a newspaper journalist for a while and one or two times a year someone would call in and say an ethnic family moved into the neighborhood and all the dogs and cats were being eaten. To which I always had the same reply: It’s not illegal and do you have the address? I’d like to give it a try. If you are so inclined:

Dog Gone

Lemon Grass Dog
•    2 lb dog meat
•    4 three-foot stalks lemongrass
•    3 tbsp Vietnamese fish sauce (nuoc mam)
•    2 tsp lime juice
•    1/2 tsp lime zest
•    Jasmine rice (if desired)
•    Rice vermicelli (if desired)
•    Baguette (if desired)

Try to ensure that it is from a medium-sized dog. The breed does not matter, unless you have certain preferences.  Mince four 3-feet stalks of fresh lemongrass. (Alternatively, use an 8 oz. package of frozen minced lemongrass.) Mix the minced lemongrass with three tablespoons of Vietnamese fish sauce, two teaspoons of lime juice, and a half teaspoon of lime zest. A recommended brand is Three Crabs Brand, but all in all, fish sauce tends to taste the same. Chop the dog meat into 1-inch pieces. Add the lemongrass marinade and stir. Leave the mixture refrigerated overnight. Either sauté, steam, or grill the meat. A recommended way to cook this dish is to skewer the meat chunks and roast it in a rotisserie oven.

Cat Braisé
•    1 cat cut in serving-sized pieces dusted in flour with salt and pepper
•    1/4 c. extra virgin olive oil
•    6 artichokes
•    2 1/4″ thick slices of slab bacon, diced
•    1 small sweet onion, diced
•    4 cloves garlic, minced
•    1 carrot, diced
•    1 lemon
•    3 small tomatoes, peeled, seeded, and diced
•    1/2 c. dry white wine
•    2-4 c. homemade chicken broth
•    garni of 4 flat parsley stems, 6 leafy thyme branches, 1 bay leaf tied up with kitchen twine Salt and pepper
•    1/4 c chopped flat-leaf parsley (optional)

Snap the leaves off the artichokes until only the tender inner leaves remain. Snap off the stem. Trim the remaining green bits from the bottom of the artichoke, and cut off the inner leaves in a bunch at the point where they are very tender. Pare the tough green outer layer off the remaining stem, pairing the stem into a point. Now cut the artichoke bottom into quarters and remove the choke with a sharp knife from each quarter. Rinse to remove any traces of foin (“hay”) and drop them into a bowl of water acidulated with the juice of half a lemon.

Heat two tablespoons olive oil in a large heavy casserole or Dutch oven. Dredge the cat pieces in seasoned flour, shaking off excess. Brown over medium heat, turning regularly, until golden on all sides. Remove cat pieces to a plate and dump any oil remaining in the pan. Add one tablespoon of the remaining oil and the bacon dice.  Sauté until cooked but not “crisp”. Add the remaining tablespoon of oil and the onion and carrot. Saute for five minutes, then add the artichoke quarters and the garlic, stir one minute, and add the tomatoes and the white wine. Turn up the heat and reduce until syrupy, stirring constantly, for about five minutes. Lay the bouquet garni on top of the vegetables. Arrange the cat pieces on top, together with any juice accumulated in the plate.

Pour in enough broth to come halfway up the sides of the cat pieces. Cover and bring to a simmer. Continue to simmer over very low heat about one hour or cook in the oven at 350Fº for the same amount of time. The cat should be just tender and part readily from the bone. Don’t overcook or it will become dry. Check the liquid level frequently and add more broth if necessary. Turn the cat pieces once.

When done, remove the cat pieces to a warm platter and arrange the vegetables, removed with a slotted spoon, around them. Cover and keep warm. Strain the remaining pan juices into a smaller saucepan and reduce over high heat, skimming frequently, until reduced by one third. Pour over the platter and serve immediately. Sprinkle with finely chopped flat-leaf parsley if you like.

Cat Call, or Cat Tales

{ 2 comments }